Home
Trips & Rates
Gallery
Reviews
Reports
Target Species
Meet the Captain

Learn More

My Trips

Tontine Fishing Charters Customer Reviews

100% would recommend thumbsup_icon
[object Object][object Object][object Object][object Object][object Object][object Object]

5/5

From 16
verified reviews

jackAiIconJack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Patrick Dennehy consistently delivers exceptional fishing results with Tontine Fishing Charters, earning praise from customers who catch stripers, haddock, and seabass on nearly every trip. Reviewers highlight how Patrick and his crew work tirelessly to keep lines in the water, moving to productive spots when needed and ensuring non-stop action. His expertise shines through as he takes groups to the best honey holes and provides all necessary equipment, with many noting they learned more in one trip than previous fishing experiences. Customers appreciate Patrick's patient, friendly approach that works equally well for experienced anglers and complete beginners. Families especially enjoy his accommodating nature, with older guests and children alike having memorable experiences. Many reviewers mention Patrick's willingness to answer questions, help with fish handling, and create a comfortable atmosphere filled with laughter. Regular customers return for repeat trips and consistently recommend Tontine Fishing Charters as the top choice in the area.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Stripers
Non-Stop Action
Honey Holes
Patient Guidance
Family Friendly
Expert Captain
Repeat Customers
Productive Spots

Photos from Real Customers

See all images
review imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview imagesreview images

Book Your Next Trip With Us

Loading...

All Reviews

RJ

Ronald Johnson

September 19, 2026
Trip - Catch Big Ocean Fish Deep in the Open Atlantic Waters on September 19, 2026

Great captain and mate, very nice boat, looking forward to our next trip.

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
CP

Charles Putnam

September 10, 2026
Trip - Catch Big Ocean Fish Deep in the Open Atlantic Waters on September 10, 2026

Such a great time funny that both the Captain and deck hand are both named Matt great company and experience

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
ME

Mind Evolution

September 10, 2026
Trip - Catch Big Ocean Fish Deep in the Open Atlantic Waters on September 10, 2026

This is the best captain i have experienced and looking forward to going out with him again

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
JB

Jon Blanchette

July 15, 2026
Trip - Spend a Full Day Catching Ocean Fish Far From Shore on July 15, 2026

Outstanding Captain, Mate and Boat. They will stand on their heads to find the fish. Trips are a lot of fun and coolers almost always crammed with tasty fish. I give this Vessel the highest possible rating.

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
JR

Jason Russell

June 21, 2026
Trip - Catch Big Ocean Fish Deep in the Open Atlantic Waters on June 21, 2026

Amazing day some awesome guy on this boat. Had an amazing time

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
JR

Jason Russell

June 10, 2026
Trip - Catch Big Ocean Fish Deep in the Open Atlantic Waters on June 10, 2026

Amazing day some awesome guy on this boat. Had an amazing time

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
JD

James Devine

April 18, 2026
Trip - Catch Big Ocean Fish Deep in the Open Atlantic Waters on April 18, 2026

Great trip, made possible by Capt Matt! Has put us on fish every time. Expect to book again in the future.

review imagesreview imagesreview images
Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
RD

Roman Dudus

October 17, 2025
Trip - Spend a Full Day Catching Ocean Fish Far From Shore on October 17, 2025

This is a Great fishing charter and Capt Matti knows the area like the back of their hand!! Had a Great Day out on the water and caught a bunch of fish. Definitely coming back and would recommend them to anyone!! Thank You Capt Matti!! And deck mate Matt for all your hard work, it doesn't go unnoticed.

review images
Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
BL

Bob Lynch

August 11, 2025
Trip - Catch Big Striped Bass Along the Scenic New Hampshire Coast on August 11, 2025

We had a great time fishing with Captain Matt. We all caught some fish and a good number of us also landed some striper. Our 1st Matt was always helpful and ready when needed.

review imagesreview imagesreview images+1
Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
MB

Mark Brough

July 29, 2025
Trip - Catch Big Striped Bass Along the Scenic New Hampshire Coast on July 29, 2025

Capt Matt and Mate Matt put us on some stripers and the group had a good time.

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
AF

ANDY FENG

April 12, 2025
Trip - Spend a Full Day Catching Ocean Fish Far From Shore on April 12, 2025

Thanks Captain, we all had a great time.

review imagesreview images
Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0
KL

Kevin Leclerc

August 26, 2024
Trip - Spend a Full Day Catching Ocean Fish Far From Shore on August 26, 2024

Another great trip on the Tontini. They always put you on the fish and aren’t afraid to move to keep the fish coming in the boat. Everyone in my party went home with heavy bag of fillets. Love these guys and worth every penny. My buddies and I can’t wait to go again in October. See you soon

Was this helpful ?Helpful Icon 0

Premier Ocean Fishing Out of Historic Rye Harbor

Customer Reviews for Tontine Fishing Charters in Rye, NH

Choosing the right New Hampshire deep sea charter comes down to trust, consistency, and a proven track record on the water. At Tontine Fishing Charters, our guest reviews reflect the heart of what we do: delivering exceptional trip quality, heavy coolers, and lasting memories along the picturesque Rye shoreline. Whether it’s a family celebrating a child’s first striped bass catch or dedicated anglers returning year after year to haul in limits of Atlantic cod, haddock, and pollock, our client feedback highlights the unmatched dedication of Captain Matthew Krajewski. Reading through these real angler experiences gives prospective guests an honest, behind-the-scenes look at our spacious boat, top-tier tackle, and hands-on guidance that make every ocean outing both productive and fun.

From serene early morning departures out of Rye Harbor to thrilling rod-bending battles over offshore reefs, these fishing charter reviews showcase why first-timers and seasoned sport fishermen alike rank us among the top Rye NH charter boats. Visitors frequently note our crew’s patient instruction, expert local knowledge, and seamless fish cleaning service that sends everyone home with fresh, delicious white fish fillets. We take immense pride in turning single outings into lifelong traditions, backing every voyage with safety, professional expertise, and authentic New England hospitality. See what others are saying and book your trip today to secure your place on the water!

Follow Us

Facebook

Navigate

Home

Trips & Rates

Gallery

Reviews

Reports

Target Species

Meet the Captain

Gift Card

FAQ

Contact Us

FEATURED

Striper Hunt

Deep Sea Haul

Bass Basics

Ocean Bounty

Explore

Inshore Catch

New Hampshire Fishing at its finest

Ready to turn your New Hampshire ocean vision into a fishing story you will talk about for years? Secure your private date with Tontine Fishing Charters in Rye, NH today and bring home a heavy cooler of fresh catches!

More about Tontine Fishing Charters

© Copyright 2026. All rights reserved.

Powered by Guidesly

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Sitemap